Back to Home
Josh Simcosky, recovery coach and author

You Would Think • Faith & Relationships

Codependency &
People-Pleasing

You Can Care Without Losing Yourself.

Always fixing, always agreeing, always trying to keep the peace—and still feeling resentful? I help men examine the fear and beliefs underneath these patterns, practice honest boundaries, and take responsibility for their own lives.

Explore One-on-One CoachingStart With One Small Change

Recognize the Cycle

When Keeping the Peace Costs You Honesty

Recognizing a pattern isn't a diagnosis. Caring, serving, and compromising aren't problems in themselves. The question is whether fear, self-neglect, or control is driving the way you relate.

Look Beneath the Behavior

What I Mean by Codependency

I use this word to talk about relationship patterns where our sense of worth or safety becomes tied to being needed, earning approval, or managing another person's life. People-pleasing can be one expression of that pattern; it isn't the whole story.

Sometimes what looks like kindness is also an attempt to avoid conflict or control how someone sees us. That doesn't make us bad people. It gives us something honest to examine—and a place to begin practicing differently.

In my approach, Christian faith isn't a reason to disappear inside someone else's needs. Love, truth, surrender, and personal responsibility belong together. We can serve freely without treating every request as an obligation.

A Different Way to Relate

From Being Needed to Being Honest

Support Without Rescuing

I encourage people to offer care without hiding consequences or doing another person's work for them. Helping can be generous; taking over can keep both people stuck.

Honesty Instead of Approval

A yes isn't honest if you're only saying it to avoid disappointment. We practice naming what we need and what we can offer without making someone else's approval the deciding factor.

Responsibility Instead of Control

Your choices, words, and follow-through are yours. Someone else's feelings and willingness to change are not. Recovery asks us to own our part—not manage every outcome.

Put It Into Practice

Start With One Situation, Not Every Relationship

Choose a low-stakes situation where you usually overcommit, rescue, or hide what you really think. These are starting points to adapt—not rules for every relationship.

  1. Step 01

    Pause Before the Automatic Yes

    Try: “Let me think about what I can commit to.” Notice what you're afraid will happen if you don't immediately agree.

  2. Step 02

    Ask What Is Actually Yours

    Write down your responsibility in this situation, then the other person's. Be specific: your honesty is yours; their approval isn't.

  3. Step 03

    Choose One Honest Response

    Try: “I can't take that on this week,” or “I can listen, but I can't make this decision for you.” Choose a response that fits your real capacity.

  4. Step 04

    Follow Through With Support

    Notice the guilt or urge to rescue without immediately acting on it. Talk with a trusted person who can help you reflect, keep your word, and adjust thoughtfully.

If you face threats, coercion, or abuse, prioritize safety and seek qualified local support. Appeasing someone can be a survival response, not a personal failing. A direct confrontation may not be safe.

Explore Practical Boundaries

Support for the Deeper Work

Resources & Next Steps

One-on-One Recovery Coaching for Men

I'll help you examine fear, resentment, people-pleasing, and control through biblical 12-step principles, boundaries, and practical accountability. The work is about your choices—not making someone else change.

Learn About Men's Coaching

You May Be Right, But What If You're Wrong?

My book offers 12 Steps of Recovery for Every Christian's Heart—a practical framework for self-examination, surrender, and questioning what we keep defending. Orders include a physical copy and a Free Companion Workbook.

Explore the Book

You Would Think Podcast

Keep exploring recovery, relationships, faith, and boundaries with me—and what it takes to live differently.

Listen to You Would Think

Begin With Your Part

You Don't Have to Earn the Right to Be Honest

If you're a man ready to stop repeating the same relationship patterns, let's start with an honest conversation about what needs to change in your own life.

Start 1-on-1 CoachingExplore Christian Recovery

This is educational guidance, not a diagnosis. Coaching is not therapy or medical treatment and doesn't replace professional mental health care.